The new Blogger.com — an ugly duckling?
The blogging platform Blogger relaunched this week with a new look
and new features, and drew praise in Adam Javůrek's post
A new and better Blogger.com! and Radek Hulán's
Blogger.com — a great system from Google!. My experience
with the new features in Blogger has been a lot worse. Blogger is the blogging and publishing platform
Dagblog runs on.
Since Monday, Blogger has put me through several anxious moments and cost me a lot of time. The much-praised
features such as comments and per-post archives are more of a nightmare. But let's take them one at a time.
Archive page
Blogger used to have a template for defining an archive page. The archive page could contain links to
older posts grouped by day, week or month. The new Blogger should still have this option (screenshot),
but for reasons I can't fathom, it doesn't appear in the publishing interface.
That leaves no way to set the template and create an archive page.
Per-post archives
Each post gets its own page with a URL in the form http://xyz/rok/mesic/titulek-příspěvku.
Per-post archiving has several drawbacks and can fortunately be turned off.
The biggest problem is duplication, since a post appears in the archive and also
has its own page. Another drawback is that the page name comes from the post title. The people who built it apparently
didn't think anyone would write titles in a language other than English. For the title
“Dobrá rada nad zlato: vylepšujeme kód” (“Good advice is worth more than gold: improving the code”), it generates the page
dobr-rada-nad-zlato-vylepujeme-kd-vte.html. Another drawback is the huge number of files Blogger generates
and uploads over FTP when you republish. Dagblog has around 240 posts, so it generates 240 files,
and that doesn't count the archives I mentioned under duplication. Republishing took about 45 minutes.
Comments
The first big disappointment is that only posts published through the new interface have comments.
Older posts simply lack them. Maybe the problem is in Dagblog's main template, but
for all my efforts, unlike Jirka Hradil
, I couldn't get it to work. Another drawback is the way commenting works. Unless you're a registered Blogger user,
you can only comment anonymously, with no way to enter a name, email address or website. Comments are
tied to per-post archives. If you want to use comments, you have to turn on
per-post archiving.
On the other hand, Blogger introduced new design templates (you're looking at one right now), profiles and
other little changes, including a new web interface. My own feelings are mixed.
Clearly a lot of work went into Blogger, and features that were missing
such as comments, post management and previews are in place. At the same time, some features feel unfinished,
as if the developers are waiting for users to weigh in.
Related articles
Related CZ Podcast episodes
- #217 · Ivo Lukačovič
On Windy, JavaScript and building companies. · Czech audio
- #3 · Java 6 SE, Vývoj webových aplikací
Dagi and Filemon discuss Java 6 and web application frameworks. · Czech audio